Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Critical Commons

Sections
Document Actions

Freud and TV contain female desire

by ccManager
Commentary summary:
Freud and a television set are used to contain female desire

Text Commentary:

A pretentious undergraduate's interpretation of Freud is used to explain the conflicts of domestic desire for the white middle class in Sirk's All That Heaven Allows. Sirk's use of costuming and production design serve as a counterpoint to the repressed pseudo-intellectualism and conservatism of spoiled children. Formally, this scene also serves as an opening bookend for the image of Jane Wyman framed and trapped in the reflection of a TV screen delivered as a substitute for romantic fulfillment.

By the time the TV set is delivered as a Christmas present, Wyman has foregone her one chance at happiness with a younger man in order to preserve her relationship with her grown children. The revelation that both her daughter and son will soon be starting new chapters of their lives makes Wyman realize that she will soon be abandoned and alone. The arrival of the television set signifies her impending imprisonment in the domestic sphere, even as it promises to deliver "life's parade" right into her living room.


Keywords

Related Clips

Related Clips
Copyright 2010, by the Contributing Authors. Cite/attribute Resource. ccManager. (2011, November 17). Freud and TV contain female desire. Retrieved May 17, 2012, from Critical Commons Web site: http://criticalcommons.org/Members/ccManager/commentaries/freud-and-tv-contain-female-desire. This work is licensed under a No Copyright; No Rights Reserved.